[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

[Bacula-devel] Vbackup feature


I'm a bit burned out from intensive bug fixing over the last couple of months, 
so decided to do something totally new yesterday.  I started implementing 
what I call Virtual Backup or Vbackup, which is essentially project #3 "Merge 
multiple backups (Synthetic Backup or Consolidation)".

In attempting to implement it, I've realized a few things: 

1. It is probably better to implement it as a new "level" under the normal 
Backup code, for example "level=vbackup".  The resulting output will be  
recorded in the catalog as a "Full".

2. In most all respects it must behave much like a Migration job in that it 
does not use a FD, it reads an existing set of backups, and writes them to a 
new Volume.

3. One difference from a Migration job is that all the old jobs remain 
unchanged (i.e. like a Copy).  

4. Another difference is that it has many fewer features in that it simply 
finds all the current backup records and copies them.  There are no 
complicated selection criteria.

5. Like the Migration and Copy jobs, the input Pool (from where it reads the 
currently backed up data) and the output Pool (where it writes the merged 
data) must be different.  This ensures that the job does not attempt to read 
and write to the same device, which just will not work.

Well the problem with the above -- principally item #5 is consider the 

You have a job J1, which does a Full, one or more Diff backups, then any 
number of Inc backups all going to Pool P1.  At some point in time (possibly 
via the Schedule), you run a vbackup level, so it finds all the current 
backup files (Full, last Diff, and all later Inc) and copies the data from 
the input Pool (P1) to the output Pool (P2).

Now, if you then redo a normal Full backup and restart with Diff and Inc jobs 
again, all will work. 

However, it is much more likely that you will then continue doing incremental 
backups (no more Full or Diffs).  At some point later, you want to do another 
vbackup to "consolidate" all the Inc backups, and now the process fails, 
because you are going to need to read from Pools P2 (Full produced by the 
vbackup) and P1 (new Incs), and you will attempt to write to P2, which will 
not work.

Thus without some other mechanism to move Volumes from Pool to Pool, a setup 
like described above won't work, and I suspect this is what will be done the 
most frequently (i.e. do only one Full and there after vbackups when there 
are enough Incs to warrant a consolidation).

Any comments?

Sponsored by: SourceForge.net Community Choice Awards: VOTE NOW!
Studies have shown that voting for your favorite open source project,
along with a healthy diet, reduces your potential for chronic lameness
and boredom. Vote Now at http://www.sourceforge.net/community/cca08
Bacula-devel mailing list

This mailing list archive is a service of Copilotco.